Over-sterile and germ-free homes ‘could be behind leukaemia in children’

A controversial study suggests that children shouldn’t be kept in over-sterile environments (Picture: Getty)

An over-sterile germ-free environment in the first year of life is one of the major causal factors behind childhood leukaemia, a controversial study suggests.

Coupled with unlucky genetics, it can leave a child vulnerable to common infections such as flu triggering the disease, says a leading expert.

***ILLUSTRATION REQUEST*** This is what it's like to wait for a kidney transplant on the national organ donor waiting list (Rosy Edwards)I’m going to need a transplant – I still don’t want opt-out organ donation to become law

Professor Mel Greaves, from the Institute of Cancer Research in London, claims the most common form of childhood leukaemia – acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) – could be prevented by ‘priming’ infants’ immune systems by exposing them to harmless bugs.

If the theory is backed by more evidence, a preventative treatment – possibly involving probiotic bacterial supplements – could be trialled in the next five years.

The research, published in the journal Nature Reviews Cancer, is based on a compilation of more than 30 years of work around the world investigating the origins of the disease.

A leading expert said that germ-free environments can leave a child vulnerable to common infection (Picture: Getty)

Speaking at a press briefing in London, Prof Greaves said: ‘All the evidence is comprehensive. This is the bottom line for me – ALL is a paradox of progress in society.

‘The research strongly suggests that ALL has a clear biological cause, and is triggered by a variety of infections in predisposed children whose immune systems have not been properly primed.

thumbnail for post ID 7790975I caught Lyme disease after being bitten by a tick at a BBQ in north London

‘It also busts some persistent myths about the causes of leukaemia, such as the damaging but unsubstantiated claims that the disease is commonly caused by exposure to elecromagnetic waves or pollution.’

The theory could explain why ALL, which affects white blood cells, is more prevalent in affluent societies where infants are shielded from infection.

It may also be the reason why babies that are not breastfed, do not mix with other children in nurseries, are born by Caesarian section, or do not have siblings are more likely to develop the disease.

ALL is rare, affecting about one in 2,000 UK children per year, but can have a devastating impact on families despite a high cure rate.

Its likely causes have been debated for 100 years with a host of possible trigger factors proposed, including radiation, mobile phones, wi-fi, power-lines, and exposure to pollutant chemicals.

Prof Greaves’ own research points towards a two-step process of genetic changes leading to the disease in children with abnormally formed immune systems.

The first, which may affect up to 5% of children, produces a population of pre-malignant cells but in the vast majority of cases never results in cancer.

Children who have the first mutation are left vulnerable to a second genetic ‘hit’ if their immune system has not developed properly, it is claimed. The trigger for the second mutation might be a common infection, such as seasonal flu, which sets off an uncontrolled inflammatory response.

In laboratory tests, susceptible mice reared in an ultra-clean germ-free environment developed ALL when they were later exposed to common infectious bugs.

Historical records show ‘spikes’ of childhood leukaemia cases have come six months after flu epidemic peaks.

Prof Greaves explained the immune system consisted of a network that was not hard-wired at birth.

At an early stage in life, it needed infection to model and set itself up in the right way.

He said parents should ‘in no way’ be blamed for children developing leukaemia, but advised them to be ‘less fussy about common or trivial infections’.

He also urged them to encourage contact between their babies and ‘as many other children as possible’ in the first year of life.

Prof Greaves said: ‘I hope this research will have a real impact on the lives of children. The most important implication is that most cases of childhood leukaemia are likely to be preventable.’

The research is a new spin on the ‘hygiene hypothesis’ that has already linked Type 1 diabetes, multiple sclerosis and childhood allergies to over-clean early environments.

Professor Charles Swanton, chief clinician at Cancer Research UK, said: ‘Childhood leukaemia is rare and it’s currently not known what or if there is anything that can be done to prevent it by either medical professionals or parents.

‘We want to assure any parents of a child who has or has had leukaemia, that there’s nothing that we know of that could have been done to prevent their illness.’

Dr Alasdair Rankin, research director at blood cancer charity Bloodwise, which funds Prof Greaves’ work, said: ‘Current treatments for childhood leukaemia are not always successful, and even when they are, can have severe short and long-term side effects, so research to find kinder treatments is very important.

‘If we could stop this type of leukaemia from happening in the first place it would be enormously exciting, but many more questions still need to be answered in the research lab before we will know for sure whether that could become a reality.’


Read More   How to create a period-friendly workplace

Leave a Reply

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.